Email Deliverability January 3, 2026 9 min read

What Causes Email Bounce Backs?

Short answer: Email bounce backs occur when messages cannot be delivered to the recipient's mailbox. The most common causes are invalid email addresses, authentication failures (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), poor sender reputation, full mailboxes, and server-side blocks from mailbox providers like Gmail, Yahoo, and Outlook.

When an email bounces, the receiving mail server sends a notification back to the sender explaining why the message could not be delivered. Understanding these bounce reasons is essential for maintaining list hygiene, protecting sender reputation, and ensuring your messages reach their intended recipients.

We process billions of emails and have identified the primary categories of bounce backs that senders encounter. Each type requires a different response, and knowing how to interpret bounce codes can mean the difference between a quick fix and an ongoing deliverability problem.

Hard Bounces vs. Soft Bounces

Email bounces fall into two main categories, and the distinction matters for how you handle them.

Hard Bounces (Permanent Failures)

Hard bounces indicate a permanent delivery failure. The receiving server has determined that the message cannot be delivered now or in the future. These generate 5XX SMTP error codes and require immediate action.

Common hard bounce causes include:

Hard-bounced addresses should be removed from your mailing list immediately. Continuing to send to these addresses damages your sender reputation and can trigger additional blocks.

Soft Bounces (Temporary Failures)

Soft bounces indicate a temporary delivery problem. The message might be deliverable if retried later. These generate 4XX SMTP error codes.

Common soft bounce causes include:

Most email platforms automatically retry soft bounces for a period of 24-72 hours. If an address consistently soft bounces across multiple campaigns, it should eventually be treated as a hard bounce.

The 7 Primary Causes of Email Bounce Backs

1. Invalid or Non-Existent Email Addresses

The most common cause of bounces is sending to addresses that do not exist. This happens when:

Yahoo's sender documentation notes that recipients who do not exist result in permanent 553 or 554 rejections. There is no way to deliver to these addresses, and attempting to do so signals that you are not maintaining your list properly.

2. Authentication Failures

Mailbox providers increasingly require proper email authentication. According to Yahoo's sender requirements, all senders must implement SPF or DKIM at minimum, while bulk senders must implement both plus DMARC.

Authentication-related bounces occur when:

Yahoo specifically states that messages failing authentication against DMARC or DKIM policies will receive 553 or 554 permanent rejections. We recommend checking your authentication setup using DNS lookup tools if you see authentication-related bounce codes.

3. Poor Sender Reputation

Mailbox providers track your sending behavior over time. If your IP addresses or domains develop a negative reputation, your messages will be blocked or bounced.

Reputation problems leading to bounces include:

When reputation triggers bounces, you will typically see 421 or 451 temporary deferrals first, followed by 553 or 554 permanent blocks if the behavior continues. Yahoo's documentation notes that "unusual traffic patterns from your sending server's IP address" trigger these deferrals.

4. Content and Policy Violations

Messages can bounce when their content violates the receiving server's policies. This includes:

Yahoo explicitly blocks messages containing "viruses, phishing attempts, ransomware, malicious software, and URLs related to these types of content." These result in permanent 554 rejections.

5. Server and Infrastructure Issues

Technical problems with sending or receiving infrastructure can cause bounces:

These issues often affect all mail to a particular domain rather than individual addresses. If you see bounces across multiple recipients at the same domain, infrastructure problems are likely.

6. Rate Limiting and Volume Issues

Mailbox providers limit how much mail they accept from individual senders. Exceeding these limits causes temporary bounces:

Yahoo's documentation notes that they will "terminate connections after a maximum number of messages per-connection has been reached." These are temporary deferrals (4XX codes) rather than permanent rejections.

7. Recipient Mailbox Issues

Sometimes the problem is on the recipient's end rather than yours:

These typically generate soft bounces that may resolve when the recipient clears space or reactivates their account.

Understanding SMTP Bounce Codes

When emails bounce, the receiving server returns an SMTP status code that indicates the reason. Understanding these codes helps diagnose problems quickly.

4XX Codes (Temporary Failures)

5XX Codes (Permanent Failures)

The text accompanying these codes provides additional context. Always read the full bounce message, as it often includes specific instructions for resolving the issue.

How to Reduce Email Bounce Rates

Reducing bounces requires addressing each potential cause systematically.

Implement Email Verification

Verify email addresses at the point of collection using real-time validation. This catches typos, fake addresses, and role-based addresses before they enter your list. For existing lists, run periodic hygiene checks to identify addresses that have become invalid.

Configure Authentication Properly

Ensure all three authentication protocols are correctly configured:

Monitor and Protect Sender Reputation

Use postmaster tools from Gmail, Yahoo, and Microsoft to monitor your reputation metrics. Keep complaint rates below 0.3%, remove bounced addresses promptly, and avoid sudden volume changes that trigger defensive measures.

Maintain List Hygiene

Remove hard-bounced addresses immediately and permanently. Suppress soft-bounced addresses after consistent failures. Re-engage inactive subscribers or remove them from active sending. Never purchase email lists.

Follow RFC Standards

Ensure your messages comply with RFC 5321 (SMTP) and RFC 5322 (message format) standards. This includes proper header formatting, valid MIME types, and correct date formatting.

Best Practice: Monitor Bounce Rates by Category

Track hard bounces and soft bounces separately. A sudden spike in hard bounces often indicates a list quality problem, while increasing soft bounces may signal reputation issues or receiving server problems. Normal hard bounce rates should be under 0.5%, and soft bounces under 2%.

What To Do When Emails Start Bouncing

If you experience a sudden increase in bounces, follow this diagnostic process:

  1. Review bounce codes: Categorize bounces by SMTP code to identify the primary cause
  2. Check blacklists: Use MXToolbox or similar tools to verify your IPs are not listed
  3. Verify authentication: Confirm SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are correct and passing
  4. Review recent changes: Consider whether list imports, volume changes, or content changes coincided with the bounce increase
  5. Check postmaster tools: Review Gmail Postmaster Tools and Yahoo Sender Hub for reputation alerts
  6. Contact support: For persistent blocks, use the mailbox provider's sender support forms

Document the bounce codes and any patterns you observe. This information is essential if you need to request unblocking or work with your email platform's deliverability team.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a hard bounce and a soft bounce?
A hard bounce is a permanent delivery failure caused by invalid email addresses, non-existent domains, or permanent blocks. A soft bounce is a temporary failure caused by full mailboxes, server downtime, or rate limiting. Hard bounces require immediate address removal, while soft bounces may resolve on retry.
What is a good bounce rate for email campaigns?
A healthy bounce rate is below 2% for most industries. Rates above 5% indicate serious list quality issues and can damage sender reputation. Yahoo and Gmail recommend keeping spam complaint rates below 0.3%, and high bounce rates often correlate with complaint problems.
How do I fix email authentication failures causing bounces?
To fix authentication bounces, verify your SPF record includes all sending IP addresses, ensure DKIM is properly configured with valid key pairs, and implement DMARC with alignment between your From header domain and authentication domains. Use tools like MXToolbox to validate your DNS records.
Why are my emails bouncing with a 550 error?
A 550 error indicates a permanent rejection. Common causes include: recipient address does not exist, your IP is blacklisted, authentication failed against the recipient's DMARC policy, or your content violated the mailbox provider's policies. Check the full bounce message for specific details.
How long should I wait before removing soft-bounced addresses?
Retry soft-bounced addresses for 24-72 hours before suppressing them temporarily. If an address soft-bounces consistently over 3-5 separate campaigns, consider treating it as a hard bounce and removing it from your list. Some platforms handle this automatically based on bounce patterns.

Ready to Improve Your Email Deliverability?

SortedIQ helps high-volume senders maximize inbox placement and sender reputation.

Talk to Our Team